|
ALHABTOOR
INFORMATION AND RESEARCH DEPARTMENT
As
President Bush prepares to unleash war on
the people of
Iraq
,
it is time to reflect on what other costs
this invasion might incur.
The
Economic Fallout
An attack on Iraq by America
would have a dramatic affect on the price
of oil with prices expect to rise to
between $30 and $40 a barrel in a short
term, which will impact on world growth
prospects and will likely slow further any
improvement in world markets. Regionally,
the only certain prediction that can be
made is that an invasion of
Iraq
will bring a period of uncertainty to Arab
regional economies and unsettle local
stock markets. It is clear that Arab
countries, such as
Syria
,
UAE and
Jordan
,
who have established strong trade ties
with
Iraq
,
have the most to lose. However, if, the as
the analysts predict, the military strike
is swift, lasting no more than a few
months, then it is predicted that the
price of oil will plunge to $20 a barrel.
As the Americans will bring Iraqi oil (an
estimated 6 million barrels a day), back
on stream after lifting sanctions, the
price could go even lower, as
Saudi
Arabia
and other OPEC countries resist cutting
production to accommodate additional Iraqi
oil exports.
The
Cost to The American Taxpayer
It is estimated by the US
House Budget Committee that the total cost
of another war with
Iraq
will cost the American people around 100
billion dollars, if, as the Whitehouse
predict the war is won in a relatively
short time. Unlike the 1991 Gulf War, when
the Gulf countries contributed over 80per
cent of the cost of the war, the American
taxpayer will have to pick up the entire
bill. This will considerably increase the
US
budget deficit and require the Government
to borrow extra money to finance the war,
Putting pressure on the Federal Reserve to
increase interest rates at a time when
lower interests rates are needed to offset
the
US
’s
current economic weakness. However, the
costs to American taxpayer would not stop
there. If
America
is successfully in forcing regime change
on
Iraq
,
it is estimated by some economists that
the cost of reconstruction a war ravaged
Iraq
,
supplying humanitarian assistance and
maintaining a force on the ground to
ensure stability, will cost another 50
billion annually. As
America
may have to stay engaged in
Iraq
for many years, the cost of maintaining
the peace in the country could eventually
outstrip the cost of the war itself. Even
staying for five years will cost the
Americans another 250 billion dollars.
Impact
on the Gulf Countries
The
Gulf
States
have taken steps to diversify their
economies. However, almost all of them are
still dependant on oil for their income.
Lower oil prices
will depress Gulf
economies, rising internal and external
imbalances. GDP already fails to match
population growth in most of the
Gulf
States
,
with
Saudi
Arabia
most affected. The average age of
Saudi Arabia
’s
22million people is 16 years and, as the
economy slows, unemployment will become an
increasingly important issue.
Saudi Arabia
already suffers from enormous internal
debt, estimated at $168 billion in 2001,
accounting for 95 per cent of its GDP. Any
lengthy period of low oil prices will only
exacerbate its problems. The UAE and
Bahrain
are better off because they have built up
viable non-oil sectors. However, they too,
will suffer from an invasion of
Iraq
.
Both of these countries, along with
Egypt
,
Lebanon
and
Oman
have over the last decade been developing
a profitable and growing tourism sector.
This will inevitably suffer, for just as
after
September
11th 2001
, people will stop travelling by air and hotel bookings throughout
the region will fall as holiday makers and
businessmen avoid the region seeing it as
a war zone and for fear of reprisals but
extremists. This will have a sever impact
on their economies.
"Starting
a war with
Iraq
is clearly a decision that is motivated by
George W. Bush’s desire to please the
arms and oil industries in the
United States of America
."
-Nelson
Mandela |
As stated earlier, the
countries that have the close trade ties
with
Iraq
will suffer the most from an American
invasion.
Jordan
,
Egypt
,
and
Syria
will be affected most, followed by
Lebanon
,
the UAE and
Turkey
,
as
Iraq
has become an important export market for
these countries, nearly all of whom have
trade agreement with the Iraqi regime.
If
America
is successful and trade sanctions with the
rest of the world are lifted, then a new
regime will inevitably change them, for it
would enable any new government to base
its trading relationship on economic,
rather than political interests.
Therefore, Egyptian and Syrian exports to
Iraq
would diminish as they are mainly based on
political decision. This will cost
Syria
an estimated $2 billion a year in trade
flows and
Egypt
could lose up to $2.8 billion worth of
exports, which will be a major blow to
both countries’ economies.
For
Jordan
,
an American invasion of
Iraq
would disrupt Iraqi oil to the Kingdom
that is delivered mainly by road and this
would severely affect several import
industrial sectors and the country’s
infrastructure.
A
US
attack will also have a damaging affect on
the region’s stock markets. Already,
just the threat of war has a negative
impact on their performance and seen them
fall. Nearly all regional stock markets
suffered in the first three quarters of
this year with
Palestine
,
Lebanon
,
Morocco
,
Tunisia
and
Egypt
suffering the most. The GCC stock markets
performed well in the first six months of
this year but have since fallen back. As
long as uncertainty persists in the
region, Arab stock markets are likely to
remain unsettled.
Apart from the known economic cost of an
American invasion of
Iraq
,
there may be others that are yet
unforeseen. What would be the regional and
global economic impact of Mr. Hussein
setting fire to his oilfields just as he
did to those in
Kuwait
just over a decade ago? What, if feeling
cornered and desperate, he actually uses
whatever chemical, biological and nuclear
weapons he possess on his neighbours, say
for instance Kuwait and Saudi Arabia,
crippling their oil production? These are
yet unanswered questions. President Bush,
Dick Chaney, Donald Ramsfield and all the
right wing American hawks, who have been
talking up the invasion have so far failed
to mention these possibilities.
Should either of these things
happen then the economic consequences of
America
’s reckless imperialism will devastate the
global economy and harm untold millions of
people. |